Dark matter versus modified gravity

The scenario consistent with a wealth of observations for the missing mass problem is that of weakly interacting dark matter particles. However, arguments or proposals for a Newtonian or relativistic modified gravity scenario continue to be made.

A distinguishing characteristic between the two scenarios is that dark matter particles can produce a gravitational effect, in principle, without the need of baryons while this is not the case for the modified gravity scenario where such an effect must be correlated with the amount of baryonic matter.

This image from the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope shows the galaxy cluster MACSJ0717.5+3745, one of the most massive galaxy clusters known and also the largest known gravitational lens. Credit: NASA, ESA and the HST Frontier Fields team (STScI)

In a recent paper (Lin & Ishak 2016) the authors consider ultra-faint dwarf (UFD) galaxies as a promising arena to test the two scenarios based on the above assertion. They compare the correlation of the luminosity with the velocity dispersion between samples of UFD and non-UFD galaxies, finding a trend of loss of correlation for the UFD galaxies.

For example, they find for 28 non-UFD galaxies a strong correlation coefficient of -0.688 which drops to -0.077 for the 23 UFD galaxies. Incoming and future data will determine whether the observed stochasticity for UFD galaxies is physical or due to systematics in the data.

Such a loss of correlation (if it is to persist) is possible and consistent with the dark matter scenario for UFD galaxies but would constitute a new challenge for the modified gravity scenario.

Lin & Ishak 2016 (preprint) - Ultra faint dwarf galaxies: an arena for testing dark matter versus modified gravity (arXiv)

Comments

A METHOD TO TEST THE EXISTENCE OF REGULAR BLACK HOLES

Illustration of a black hole. Image Credit & Copyright: Alain Riazuelo The existence of the singularity is an intrinsic problem of the General Relativity (GR). At the fundamentally level, the resolution of the problem of the singularity lies with the expectation that under situations where quantum effects become strong, the behavior of gravity could possibly greatly deviate from that predicted by the classical theory of GR. Regular black hole solution are proposed with the same spacetime geometry outside the horizon as the traditional black hole, but bears no singularity inside. Whether or not black hole singularities should exist, they would be covered by the black hole horizon. The black hole horizon serves as an information curtain hindering outside observers from directly observing the interior structure of the black hole, and determining that whether or not the black hole singularity does really exist. A method is needed to check the correctness of the new constructions ...

Astrophysics collection (March 11, 2016)

Latest astrophysics news Rotation curves of galaxies as a test of MOND? Galaxies are rotating with such speed that the gravity generated by their observable matter could not possibly hold them together. In a recent paper ( Haghi et al. 2016 ) the authors test the Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND). Read>> A binary origin for a central compact object (CCO)? Doroshenko et al. 2016 investigate the possible binary origin of the CCO XMMUJ173203.3-344518 . Read>> Rapidly rotating pulsars as possible sources of fast radio bursts (FRB) In a recent paper ( Lyutikov et al. 2016 ) the authors discuss possible association of fast radio bursts (FRBs) with supergiant pulses emitted by young pulsars. Read>> Supernovae from WD-WD direct collisions In recent years it was suggested that WD-WD direct collisions (probably extremely rare and occurring only in dense stellar clusters) provide an additional channel for supernova...

Dark Neutron Stars

Illustration of a neutron star. Credit: NASA/Dana Berry There is good evidence that electron-positron pair formation is not present in that section of the pulsar open magnetosphere which is the source of coherent radio emission, but the possibility of two-photon pair creation in an outer gap remains. Calculation of transition rates for this process based on measured whole-surface temperatures, combined with a survey of gamma-ray, X-ray and optical luminosities, expressed per primary beam lepton, shows that few Fermi LAT pulsars have significant outer-gap pair creation. For radio-loud pulsars with positive polar-cap corotational charge density and an ion-proton plasma there must be an outward flow of electrons from some other part of the magnetosphere to maintain a constant net charge on the star. In the absence of pair creation, it is likely that this current is the source of GeV gamma-emission observed by the Fermi LAT and its origin is in the region of the outer gap. With n...

SpaceTime

Search This Blog